Difference Between Cooperative and Commercial Banks

Download PDF 📄

Banks form the backbone of any economy, serving people, businesses, and communities with crucial financial services required for growth and stability. There are many types of banking institutions, but one must remember that cooperative banks and commercial banks are distinguished in operational goals, ownership structure, and target market. Knowledge of the difference between cooperative and commercial banks can only provide the best insight into the making of an appropriate decision. Co-operative banks are mainly concerned with the development of the community and the welfare of the members, whereas commercial banks are profit-oriented, serving the general public and businesses with a wide range of services.

Difference Between Cooperative and Commercial Banks

Cooperative banks and commercial banks have basic differences, based on their purpose, governance, and customer base. Cooperative banks are member-owned institutions that are formed to serve the financial needs of a specific community, giving more importance to collective welfare than to profits. Commercial banks, however, are corporate entities, driven by profitability and financial growth.

The principles of democracy govern cooperative banks, where every member has equal voting rights irrespective of the amount invested. On the other hand, commercial banks are governed by professional boards and shareholders with proportional voting power in respect of shares held. Services also vary between these banks. Cooperative banks offer basic banking services designed to cater to their members’ needs, whereas commercial banks offer diversified financial products, including loans, credit facilities, and investment options.

Aspect	Cooperative Banks	Commercial Banks
Ownership	Owned by members/shareholders	Owned by private/public shareholders
Objective	Welfare of members	Profit generation
Governance	Democratic; one-member-one-vote principle	Shareholder-driven; votes based on shares
Customer Base	Limited to members	Open to the general public
Services	Focused on credit and savings for members	Broad range of banking services
Reach	Rural and local areas	National and international markets
Regulation	Regulated by NABARD and state authorities	Regulated by RBI and SEBI

What Are Commercial Banks?

Commercial banks are large financial institutions that carry out their primary goal through profit maximization. In addition to accepting deposits and offering loans, they aid in trade, among others. These commercial banks assist in the economic development of a country by channeling savings into productive investments

Nature of Commercial Banks

Commercial banks are intermediaries between savers and borrowers. They accept deposits from individuals and institutions, offer interest on savings, and lend this capital at a higher interest rate to businesses and individuals in need of funds. This interest margin forms the primary source of their income.

The governance of commercial banks is professional, with the decisions made by boards of directors and management teams. Their focus is on profitability, compliance, and customer satisfaction. In contrast, cooperative banks have a rather extensive network but serve a less diverse clientele. The service from individuals to multinational companies.

Types of Commercial Banks

Commercial banks are categorized into:

Public Sector Banks (e.g., State Bank of India): Owned by the government, focusing on financial inclusion.
Private Sector Banks (e.g., HDFC Bank): Operated by private entities, emphasizing innovation and service efficiency.
Foreign Banks (e.g., HSBC): International banks offering global banking services.

Each type caters to specific market needs, contributing to the overall financial ecosystem.

Download Difference Between Cooperative and Commercial Banks PDF

Services Provided by Commercial Banks

The versatility of commercial banks is evident in the wide array of services they offer. These services address individual, business, and government needs, supporting financial stability and economic growth.

Deposit and Savings Services

Commercial banks accept deposits in multiple forms. Some of them include savings accounts, current accounts, and fixed deposits. Savings accounts are particularly for individuals as an interest-bearing account, while still giving liquidity. Current accounts are particularly designed for a business firm with overdraft facilities, providing immediate use of funds. Fixed deposits offer a person better interest rates for long-term saving, giving an ideal method of saving money in absolute safety.

Credit and Loan Facilities

One of the core services of commercial banks is lending. Personal loans, vehicle loans, and housing loans meet individual needs, while businesses benefit from working capital loans, trade credit, and term loans for expansion. Banks also provide credit card facilities, enabling cashless transactions and short-term credit for customers.

Payment and Transaction Services

Commercial banks facilitate payments through cheques, demand drafts, and electronic transfers such as NEFT, RTGS, and UPI. The advent of online and mobile banking has further revolutionized how customers access and manage their funds, offering convenience and speed.

Investment and Advisory Services

Banks provide avenues for investment, such as mutual funds, insurance products, and bonds. They also offer financial advisory services, assisting customers in making informed investment decisions.

Role of Commercial Banks in Economic Development

Commercial banks are vital for the economic progress of any nation. By mobilizing resources and facilitating capital flow, they create an environment conducive to growth and innovation.

Economic Contributions

Mobilization of Savings: Commercial banks encourage people to save their money, which is further used for productive investment. This increases the funds for industries and infrastructural developments.
Credit Creation: When commercial banks lend money to industries and people, then demand is created and boosted, and economic activity increases. Credit creation creates industrial growth and employment opportunities.
Trade and Commerce Support: Commercial banks support international trade by offering letters of credit, foreign exchange services, and trade finance.
Infrastructure Financing: Commercial banks are also involved in financing huge projects such as roads, bridges, and power plants that spur long-term economic development.
Financial Inclusion: Public sector banks have primarily been involved in bringing banking services to the unbanked population, which promotes inclusive growth.

What Are Cooperative Banks?

Cooperative banks are financial institutions established to serve specific communities or groups. Unlike commercial banks, their primary focus is on mutual aid and community development rather than profit.

Nature of Cooperative Banks

Co-operative banks work not for profit. In other words, the members own as well as use its facilities and services. Their decision making is democratic with one man one vote despite contributions. The prime aim is to offer relatively inexpensive credit facilities to members along with developmental projects on farm and rural activities.

Cooperative banks are structured at three levels:

Primary Credit Societies: Operate at the grassroots level, catering to small groups.
District Cooperative Banks: Function at the district level, acting as intermediaries between primary societies and state cooperative banks.
State Cooperative Banks: Operate at the apex level, providing policy support and funding to lower tiers.

Download Cooperative vs Commercial Banks PDF

Services Provided by Cooperative Banks

The services offered by cooperative banks are designed to meet the specific needs of their members and communities, emphasizing affordable credit and inclusive development.

Savings and Deposit Services

Cooperative banks accept deposits in the form of savings accounts, recurring deposits, and fixed deposits. These accounts are designed to encourage saving among members and provide funds for lending.

Loan Services

A significant portion of cooperative banks’ activities revolves around providing loans. They offer short-term loans for agricultural inputs, equipment purchases, and seasonal needs. Medium- and long-term loans are provided for developmental activities, such as purchasing land or building infrastructure.

Community-Oriented Services

Cooperative banks often support self-help groups (SHGs) and small businesses, providing credit to those who may not qualify for loans from commercial banks. They also play a role in government schemes aimed at rural development.

Role of Cooperative Banks in Economic Development

Cooperative banks contribute significantly to the socio-economic development of rural and underserved communities. Their focus on mutual benefit and grassroots-level operations promotes inclusive growth.

Contributions to Development

Support for Agriculture: Cooperative banks provide affordable credit for seeds, fertilizers, and equipment, boosting agricultural productivity.
Promotion of MSMEs: Small and medium enterprises receive financial support, enabling them to grow and contribute to local economies.
Women Empowerment: Many cooperative banks focus on empowering women through microfinance and self-help group initiatives.
Rural Development: By funding infrastructure projects and community welfare programs, cooperative banks enhance the quality of life in rural areas.

The impact of cooperative banks extends beyond economic benefits, fostering social cohesion and self-reliance within communities.

Cooperative vs Commercial Banks FAQs

What is the main difference between cooperative and commercial banks?

Cooperative banks are member-owned institutions focused on community welfare, whereas commercial banks prioritize profit and cater to the general public.

Who regulates cooperative and commercial banks?

Cooperative banks are regulated by NABARD and state governments, while the RBI oversees commercial banks.

What types of services do cooperative banks provide?

Cooperative banks mainly provide savings accounts, agricultural loans, and microfinance services.

How do commercial banks promote economic development?

They mobilize savings, create credit, finance infrastructure, and support trade and commerce.

Can cooperative banks compete with commercial banks?

While cooperative banks focus on specific community needs, they complement commercial banks’ broader economic activities.