Comparative Politics: Benefits, Limitations, Approaches & UPSC Notes

Comparative politics is a subdivision of political science that compares political systems, institutions, processes and behaviours in more than one country. Comparing and contrasting governance, the structure of powers (who has it? Who exercises it?) and policies, it aims to analyse the corresponding patterns, reasons and outcomes, giving an insight into global political processes and democratisation.

Comparative politics is essential for UPSC as it strengthens understanding political systems, governance models, and democratic institutions. It is mainly relevant to GS Paper 2 (Polity and Governance) under Political Science, especially in constitutional comparison, governance mechanisms, international relations, and democracy.

Learn more about the Role of Religion in Indian Politics!

What is Comparative Politics?

Comparative politics is a method of the study of political science, which consists of comparing different political systems, with the help of which the complicated nature of political phenomena is analysed. Comparative politics is achieved by carrying out. 

Comparative analyses of various political systems, structures, functions, and performances in different countries are an act that increases awareness of governance patterns and political behaviours.

The key areas of comparative politics are:

• The difference in political systems and their forms
• The interaction of the political behaviour as well as the ideology
• The formulation and implementation of the public policies
• The ideas and guidelines of governance and democracy
• The processes of political creation and political evolution

History and Evolution of Comparative Politics

The origins of comparative politics can be traced back to ancient Greek philosophers such as Aristotle. They compared the constitutions of different city-states. However, it was not until the 19th century that comparative politics emerged as a distinct subfield of political science. This was partly due to the expansion of European empires and the increasing need to understand different political systems.

Learn more about Communal Politics!

Nature and Scope of Comparative Politics

The nature of comparative politics is multifaceted, with each aspect contributing towards a broader comprehension of global political systems.

• Comparative politics adopts a global perspective, enabling comparing political systems, institutions, or behaviours across different countries.
• The nature of comparative politics extends beyond description; it is fundamentally analytical. It offers a detailed analysis of political phenomena, fostering a thorough understanding of the subject.
• Comparative politics endeavours to decipher causal relationships. It seeks to answer the 'what' and 'why' and also the 'how' – delving deeper than merely describing political phenomena to explain the cause-and-effect relationship.
• The nature of comparative politics intersects with numerous other disciplines, such as sociology, economics, and anthropology. This multidisciplinary approach provides a holistic view of political phenomena.

Learn more about the Dynamics of Indian Politics!

Advantages of comparative politics

Comparative politics is involved in explaining various political systems as well as the different systems of governance in other countries. It discovers some similarities and differences, contributing to theory-construction and policymaking. It also develops critical thinking by giving greater views on democracy, development and institutional effectiveness in alleviating political and social problems.

• Gaining knowledge
  • By comparison at the micro level, one learns about the politics of different countries. It helps us understand our own country and politics better.
• Evaluating good practices and avoiding mistakes
  • Every system innovates/develops as a response to situations. There is no paradigm shift in the Social Sciences after a few years, like Natural Science. Thus, we can benefit from research already done by someone else. For example, democracy developed in Western countries but was later imported to the 3rd world. The practice also inspires the institution of Lokpal in European countries.
• Enhances Objectivity
  • To make studies more objective. To avoid criticism of ethnocentrism. Earlier, whatever studies were made, they were criticised for being ethnocentric. It was criticised as cultural imperialism.
• Comparative method to make the enterprise more scientific. It helps in better analysis and understanding.
• It allows verification/rejection of behavioural trends and patterns of people under certain circumstances.
• How different institutions function in different atmospheres can be understood by comparative politics.

Read The Article Eighth Schedule For UPSC

Approaches of Comparative Politics

There are a variety of approaches to comparative politics, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. Some of the most common approaches include:

Traditional Approach

The traditional approach to comparative politics is based on studying formal political institutions. This includes legislatures, executives, and the judiciary. This approach focuses on the structure and functions of these institutions. It also deals with the relationships between them.

Behavioral Approach

The behavioural approach to comparative politics emerged in the mid-20th century. It emerged as a reaction to the traditional approach. Behaviourists argue that the study of formal institutions is not enough to understand how political systems actually work. They focus on the behaviour of political actors, such as voters, parties, and interest groups.

Structural Approach

The structural approach of comparative politics is directed at the social, economic, and international factors that impact any political system. In determining the following compositions, Structuralists believe that the following forces are necessary:

• The power sharing. 
• The indications are premised on the brief description of political processes.

Cultural Approach

The cultural approach to comparative politics focuses on the role of culture in shaping political systems and processes. Culturalists argue that cultural values and norms play an essential role in determining:

• how people think about politics and 
• how they take part in political life.

Rational Choice Approach

The rational choice approach to comparative politics is based on the assumption that political actors are rational actors. They make decisions based on their own self-interest. Rational choice theorists use game theory and other economic models to study political behaviour.

Learn more about organisational power and politics!

Significance of Comparative Politics

Comparative politics is important because it enhances understanding political institutions, governance and state-society relations. It gives the instruments for examining global political trends, democratisation and policy output. It can be used to compare systems, allowing assessment of best practices and further support of the knowledge of issues that various countries can encounter. The study of comparative politics is multi-beneficial:

• Comparative politics enhances comprehensive knowledge of the global political system, institutions, processes, and behaviours, thus enriching expertise and bringing an international perspective.
• Comparative politics provides the possible consequences of policy decisions by examining the corresponding policies in disparate political climates. This knowledge can affect improved policymaking and reform.
• By comparing what leads to democratic development and stability in various countries, comparative politics can assist in coming up with valuable information to support matters of strengthening the democratic systems.

Learn more about the Indian Government and Politics!

Limitations of Comparative Politics

Despite its many advantages, comparative politics is not without limitations:

• The extreme variability in political systems worldwide makes it challenging to draw precise comparisons and potentially leads to inaccurate conclusions.
• Comparative politics often overlooks the influence of unique cultural contexts on political systems, thus potentially missing crucial nuances in the analysis.
• Drawing causal inferences in comparative politics can be challenging due to the complex and interdependent nature.

Learn more about ethnicity in Indian politics!

Comparative Politics: An Essential Study for UPSC Aspirants

Comparative politics plays a significant role in preparing aspirants of the UPSC as it constitutes the Political Science and International Relations syllabus. It gives aspirants a deeper insight into political phenomena, essential in answering descriptive and analytical questions. Besides, comparative politics provides aspirants with an overarching view of the world, allowing them to understand and comment more proficiently on global events and matters.

To sum up, due to cross-disciplinary research with elaborate analyses, comparative politics is one of the cornerstones in comprehending the dynamics of the political world. Its applicability and relevance are more than academic; it can be used in policy making, governance, and cut-throat exams in UPSC, among others.

Testbook provides a set of comprehensive notes for different competitive exams. Testbook is always at the top of the list because of its best quality assured products like live tests, mocks, Content pages, GK and current affairs videos, and much more. To study more topics for UPSC, download the Testbook App now.