Constitution and Constitutionalism - Differences, Similarities and Its Definitions
Introduction
When delving into the world of political theory, two terms often crop up: constitution and constitutionalism. While they may appear synonymous, there is a nuanced but significant 'Difference Between Constitution and Constitutionalism'. This article aims to unpack these terms, providing a comprehensive understanding of their distinct meanings, implications, and interconnections. By the end of this read, you'll be well-equipped with knowledge, capable of distinguishing between the constitution and constitutionalism effectively.
UPSC Beginners Program
Get UPSC Beginners Program - 60 Days Foundation Course SuperCoaching @ just
People also like
Elaborating Differences Between Constitution and Constitutionalism
Understanding the core differences between the constitution and constitutionalism is vital to grasp the intricacies of political science. Here's a more detailed comparison using the table format to break down these two interrelated but distinct concepts.
|
Parameter |
Constitution |
Constitutionalism |
|
Nature of Concept |
A constitution is tangible, typically presented in a documented format. It serves as a concrete entity that provides a roadmap for the governance of a nation. |
On the other hand, constitutionalism is an abstract concept. It exists as an ideological perspective that promotes limited governance and emphasizes the supremacy of law. |
|
Role |
The constitution serves as the skeletal framework of a nation's political system. It provides detailed information about the government's structure, the division of power, and the legal rights and responsibilities of citizens. |
Constitutionalism plays an evaluative role. It is a philosophy that evaluates the implementation and compliance of a constitution. It ensures the powers bestowed upon the government by the constitution are exercised responsibly and not abused. |
|
Focus |
The constitution focuses on the operational aspects of governance. It details 'how' the government functions, dictating the structure, laws, and principles that guide a nation. |
Constitutionalism, conversely, concentrates on the 'limits' of governmental power. It insists on the importance of checks and balances, promoting democracy, rule of law, and safeguarding citizens' fundamental rights. |
|
Function in Democracy |
In a democratic setup, the constitution provides the procedural roadmap for democratic governance. It specifies the electoral process, the formation and functioning of governments, and the rights and duties of citizens. |
In contrast, constitutionalism in a democracy acts as the guardian of democratic values. It ensures that the principles of democracy are upheld and that no entity, including the government, can violate the supremacy of the constitution. |
|
Outcome |
The constitution's main outcome is a structured, organized, and functional system of governance that is accessible and comprehensible to its citizens. |
The primary outcome of constitutionalism is a responsible government that respects the rule of law, upholds citizens' rights, and operates within the defined constitutional boundaries. |
What is a Constitution?
A constitution refers to a set of fundamental principles or established precedents that guide the governance of a state or other organization. It acts as a compass for a nation, laying out the powers, functions of the government, and the rights and obligations of the citizens.
Defining Features of a Constitution
Important features of Constitution are as follows:
- Codified or Uncodified: Some constitutions, such as the US Constitution, are codified and contained in a single document. In contrast, countries like the UK operate under an uncodified constitution, formed of various statutes, conventions, and judicial decisions.
- Flexibility vs Rigidity: A constitution can be flexible, like the British Constitution, allowing amendments as ordinary laws. On the other hand, rigid constitutions, such as the American Constitution, require special procedures for amendments.
- Unitary or Federal Structure: In a unitary constitution, all powers rest with the central government. Conversely, a federal constitution distributes powers between the central and regional governments.
What is Constitutionalism?
Constitutionalism embodies the idea that the government's authority emanates from and is limited by a body of fundamental law. Constitutionalism cherishes the concept of a limited government, ensuring that the rulers do not possess absolute authority.
Key Principles of Constitutionalism
- Rule of Law: All individuals, including those in power, are subject to the law.
- Separation of Powers: Power is apportioned among different branches of government, typically the executive, legislative, and judiciary.
- Protection of Fundamental Rights: The constitution assures certain basic rights to the citizens.
- Free and Fair Elections: Governments are chosen through regular, free, and fair elections.
Similarities Between Constitution and Constitutionalism
While the differences between constitution and constitutionalism are quite evident, it's essential to acknowledge their similarities, which reflect their interconnectedness:
- Foundation of Governance: Both the constitution and constitutionalism lay the groundwork for governance, setting the rules and principles for the operation of a state.
- Protection of Rights: Both concepts uphold the protection of individual rights as a core principle, ensuring the state respects and protects its citizens' freedoms.
- Rule of Law: Constitution and constitutionalism mutually reinforce the principle of the rule of law, asserting that all individuals, regardless of their position, are subject to the law.
Relevance to UPSC Aspirants
For UPSC aspirants, understanding the 'Difference Between Constitution and Constitutionalism' is invaluable. This knowledge not only aids in writing answers in the General Studies paper but also serves as a foundation for understanding the functioning of democracies globally. Further, it prepares candidates for possible questions in the interview, which often include situational analyses based on constitutional principles and values of constitutionalism.
Use the Testbook App and UPSC CSE Coaching platform to boost your UPSC preparation now!
