Hindustani And Carnatic Music - Differences and Similarities

Carnatic Music developed concurrently in the southern states of India, and Hindustani Music has been developed in the northern states of India. The difference Between Hindustani And Carnatic Music is basically in the tunes of the music, and it also showcases the North-South split in India. There is a unique representation of each of the music styles characterised by different tunes and songs. There are various compositions of both Hindustani and Carnatic styles that are prominently used.

Difference between Hindustani and Carnatic Music

Difference Between Hindustani And Carnatic Music is one of the most important topics for the UPSC IAS exam. It covers a significant part of the Art & Culture subject in the General Studies Paper-1 syllabus. In this article, we shall study the Difference and Similarities Between Hindustani And Carnatic Music.

Difference between Hindustani and Carnatic Music

The difference between Hindustani and Carnatic Music is shown in the table below.

Study in detail about Bharatnatyam with this link!

What is Carnatic music?

Carnatic Music developed concurrently in the southern states of Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, and Karnataka; however, Persian Music in India's wide northern geography served as an inspiration for the subgenres of Hindustani Music.

• Carnatic Music embraces much creativity, comprised of Alpana, Niraval, Kalpanaswaram, and Ragam Thana Pallavi.
• Purandaradasa (1480–1564) is the originator of Carnatic music. He is known for codifying the Carnatic music technique. Additionally, he is credited with writing thousands of songs.
• Venkat Mukhi Swami is yet another outstanding name connected to Carnatic Music. He is revered as the founder of Carnatic music theory. Additionally, he created the "Melankara" system for categorizing south Indian ragas.

Important features of Carnatic Music

• Raga and Thalam System: There is a very sophisticated theoretical system in Carnatic music. It is based on the intricate Ragam (Raga) and Thalam system (Tala).
  • Different modes are used to categorise the ragams. These modes are known as mela, and there are 72 of them.
  • The rhythmic core of Carnatic music is the Tala (thalam).

• Varanam: Carnatic performance is divided into several parts. A composition called Varanam is typically played to open a recital. The Purvanga, or first half, and the Uttaranga, or second half, make up Varanam.
• The compositions of the kritis are set in the rag. The “Alapana” provides a technique to explain the Ragam to the audience while also giving the performer a lot of creative freedom.
• Ragam is a form of unaccompanied, free-form melodic improvisation.
• Tanam is yet another form of free rhythmic, melodic improvisation.
• Pallavi is a brief melody that has been pre-composed and is set to one cycle of Tala.

Also, check out the article on Folk theatre in India for UPSC preparation!

What is Hindustani music?

Hindustani Music has been around since the Sufi era. As a result of Persian and Mughal influences in the north, changes between Hindustani and Carnatic Music started to happen in the 12th century.

The main vocal forms of Hindustani Music are Dhrupad, Khayal, Tarana, Thumri, Dadra, and Gazals. It Emphasis on the moral construction of the song (Nadi and Samvadi swars).

Important Features of Hindustani Music

• Raga System: Hindustani music is based on the raga system. The form of the raga is also affected by the specific ascent and descent pattern of the notes, which may not be strictly linear.
• Vocal Styles: Hindustani classical music focuses mainly on the voice. The khayal, Ghazal, dhrupad, dhammar, Tarana, and thumri are the principal vocal styles connected with Hindustani classical music.
• Dhrupad Styles: Men typically sing in the Dhrupad style, using a tanpura and pakhawaj.
  • Dhrupad’s lyrics are sung in a medieval form of Hindi and frequently have a heroic theme or are in honor of a certain god.
• Khayal Style: Dhrupad has been replaced by the less rigid and more free-form khayal.
  • Khayal is a song with lyrics that range from 4 to 8 lines.
  • These few sentences serve as the performer’s foundation for improvisation.
  • Hussain Shah Sharqui, a member of the Sharqui dynasty who ruled in the 15th century, is credited with creating the Khayal style of Hindustani classical music.
• Tarana Style: Tarana is yet another vocal style of Hindustani music. Tarana songs, which express joy, are typically performed toward the conclusion of a concert.
• Thumri Style: Hindustani classical music’s informal vocal style, thumri, is supposed to have originated in the court of Nawab Wajid Ali Shah, the Nawab of Oudh.
• Ghazal Styles: Ghazal, a significant component of Hindustani Classical music, was originally a Persian style of vocal music.
  • There are many different styles of ghazal, including folk and pop.
  • Ghulam Ali, Jagjit Singh, Mehndi Hassan, and Pankaj Udhas are some famous Ghazal singers.
  • Themes in ghazals include piety, joy, and love.

Study in detail about Manipuri Dance here!

Similarities Between Hindustani and Carnatic Music

• The primary elements and foundations are the same in these two music styles, such as ragas, swaras, and talas.
• Both of these musical genres have their roots in spirituality and religion; Hindustani music developed during the Vedic era, and Carnatic music first appeared during the Bhakti movement.
• Both employ Taanpura (or Drone) as their primary Shruthi and are monophonic.
• These two types were created by the translation of the Sanskrit language.
• Both of these musical traditions employ the Sampoorna scale to describe the Janya Raga.
• Melodies are given utter importance in both the Hindustani and Carnatic styles.

Study in detail about Thangka Painting here!

Conclusion

The difference between Hindustani and Carnatic Music is represented through the different forms, songs, tunes, and styles of ragas, taranas, and gharanas. Although composition and improvisation are combined to provide Dhrupad, Khayal, or Carnatic Music, there is such a divergence here that it is impossible to understand one without understanding the other. Hence, every style is interconnected with others.

Difference Between Hindustani And Carnatic Music – Know Origin, Salient Features & Similarities for UPSC: Download PDF here

Testbook provides a set of comprehensive notes for different competitive exams. Testbook is always on the top of the list because of its best quality assured products like live tests, mocks, Content pages, GK and current affairs videos, and much more. To study more topics for UPSC, download the Testbook App now. For further information and an explanation of the topic, visit UPSC CSE Coaching here!