Testbook Logo
ExamsSuperCoachingLive ClassesFREETest SeriesPrevious Year PapersSkill AcademyPassPass ProPass Elite Rank PredictorIAS PreparationPracticeGK & Current AffairsDoubtsBlog
Pass Pro Max logo

FREE

Download the Testbook App,

For FREE 7 days of
Pass Pro Max!

Exams
Tests
SuperSuper
SuperPass
logo

Differences between Indian Government and U.S. Government - Indian Polity | Testbook.com

Both India and the United States of America are renowned for their democratic governance. India, being the world's largest democracy, and the United States, as the oldest democracy, have their unique styles of functioning. Yet, despite both being democratic republics, there are fundamental differences in their governmental structures and functioning. This article aims to elucidate these differences, which are an integral part of the polity in the UPSC syllabus .

Kickstart your preparation by attempting UPSC Previous Year Question Papers right away!

To enhance your preparation for the forthcoming exam, consider the following resources:

Supercoaching Logo

PDF icon
Study Plan Illustration

Exploring the Differences Between the Governments of India and the USA

We've broken down the differences between the two governments under specific headings for a better understanding.

Political Parties

India USA
While the Indian political landscape is dominated by two major national parties - the Indian National Congress (INC) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), numerous regional and smaller parties play a significant role in shaping the political scene. The political scene in the USA is primarily a two-party system, with the Republican Party and the Democratic Party being the major players.

Head of State

India USA
  • The Prime Minister, who is the elected head of the Government, serves as the executive head in India.
  • The President, on the other hand, is the constitutional head of state.
  • The citizens vote to elect their representatives to the Lok Sabha . The President invites the party that has won a majority of seats in the Lok Sabha to form the government.
  • The leader of the winning party assumes the role of the Prime Minister.
  • Lok Sabha elections generally occur every five years.
  • In the USA, the President serves as the Head of State.
  • Citizens vote in each state to elect members of the electoral college (popular vote) who cast electoral votes to decide the President.
  • The President serves a four-year term.

Government

India USA
  • In India, the government can lose the mandate if it fails to prove its majority in the Lok Sabha during a no-confidence motion. This could lead to mid-term elections.
  • India follows a parliamentary form of government.
  • In the USA, the President's position is not reliant on the strength of his party in Congress (the legislative body). He holds office for his four-year term unless impeached or incapacitated.
  • The USA follows a presidential form of government.

Cabinet

India USA
  • In India, the Prime Minister appoints members to his cabinet from his party or from those supporting his coalition (if it’s a coalition government).
  • In the USA, the President nominates cabinet members and sends them to the Senate for confirmation. These members need not be Congress members; they could be industry experts.

Legislative Body

India USA
  • In India, the Parliament is the supreme legislative body. It is a bicameral legislature comprising the President, the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha .
  • Members of the Lok Sabha (House of the People) are directly elected by the people. The Lok Sabha consists of 545 members.
  • Members of the Rajya Sabha (Council of States) are elected by the State legislative assemblies. The Rajya Sabha has a total membership of 245.
  • In the USA, the Congress is the legislature. It consists of two chambers: the Senate (Upper House) and the House of Representatives (Lower House).

Legislation Authority

India USA
  • In India, there is no strict separation of powers. The executive is part of the elected legislature and remains in power while the House is in session.
  • The Prime Minister cannot override the legislature to make laws. A bill becomes a law only when it is passed by both Houses and signed by the President.
  • The President can send any bill back to the parliament for reconsideration. However, if the bill is passed again, it must be signed by the President.
  • The Supreme Court has the power to strike down any law that it deems unconstitutional.
  • In the USA, there is a clear separation of powers between the executive, the legislature, and the judiciary.
  • The President can veto a law passed by the Congress. He can send it back for reconsideration or issue an executive order to bypass the Congress.
  • However, the Congress can override the veto by securing a 2/3rd majority in both Houses.

Federalism

India USA
  • India is often referred to as a case of cooperative federalism . It has a single constitution for the entire country.
  • India is neither purely federal nor purely unitary. It is a federal structure with a strong unitary bias.
  • India is a union of states, implying that states do not have the authority to secede from India.
  • The USA follows a federal system, with each state having its own constitution. Power is shared between the federal government and state governments.

Get started with your UPSC 2021 Preparation today!

Related Links
India and US Trade Relations Analysis Polity MCQs for UPSC
An Overview of India – China Relations PIB Summary
UPSC Current Affairs Updates Understanding Types of Majorities in the Indian Parliament – Indian Polity
Frequently Asked Questions

Promo Banner

UPSC Beginners Program

Get UPSC Beginners Program - 60 Days Foundation Course SuperCoaching @ just

500000
🪙 Your Total Savings ₹50000

Want to know more about this Super Coaching ?

People also like

Public Administration optional by Rahul Sharma Sir

Public Administration optional by Rahul Sharma Sir

30000(59% OFF)

12500 (Valid for 15 Months)

Hindi Literature Optional (UPSC Mains) by Prachi Choudhary Ma'am

Hindi Literature Optional (UPSC Mains) by Prachi Choudhary Ma'am

33000(73% OFF)

9000 (Valid for 15 Months)

PSIR Optional (UPSC Mains) by Kiran Anishetty Sir

PSIR Optional (UPSC Mains) by Kiran Anishetty Sir

30000(40% OFF)

18000 (Valid for 15 Months)

Report An Error

Open this in:

Testbook LogoTestbook App
ChromeChrome