Testbook Logo
ExamsSuperCoachingLive ClassesFREETest SeriesPrevious Year PapersSkill AcademyPassPass ProPass Elite Rank PredictorIAS PreparationPracticeGK & Current AffairsDoubtsBlog
Pass Pro Max logo

FREE

Download the Testbook App,

For FREE 7 days of
Pass Pro Max!

Exams
Tests
SuperSuper
SuperPass
logo

Guaranteed Pension Scheme vs Old Pension Scheme vs New Pension Scheme - Detailed Comparison

The Indian Government is considering a new pension scheme proposed by the Andhra Pradesh Government. This comes at a time when the country is evaluating the pros and cons of the Old Pension System (OPS) and the New Pension Scheme (NPS). This subject is of significant importance for those studying the Indian economy section of the UPSC syllabus .

Supercoaching Logo

PDF icon
Study Plan Illustration

An Overview of the Guaranteed Pension Scheme (GPS)

The Andhra Pradesh Government has introduced a new pension plan that is now under consideration by the Union Government.

  • The Andhra Pradesh Pension Plan is a unique pension concept that incorporates elements of both the Old Pension System (defined benefit) and the New Pension Scheme (defined contribution).
  • This program is also known as the “Guaranteed Pension Scheme” (GPS).
  • Union Finance Ministry officials have described the idea as "attractive," but emphasize that it requires further examination.

Features of the Guaranteed Pension Scheme

  • Under GPS, employees who contribute 10% of their basic salary every month, matched by a 10% contribution from the state government, can receive a guaranteed pension equivalent to 33% of their final salary.
  • If employees choose to contribute a higher 14% of their monthly salary, matched by a 14% government contribution, they can receive a guaranteed pension of 40% of their last drawn salary.
  • The scheme combines elements of both the New Pension Scheme and the Old Pension System (defined benefit) (defined contribution). It offers two options for a “defined benefit” and requires a monthly “defined contribution” from employees.

The Old Pension Scheme:

  • This scheme assures a post-retirement income for life.
  • Usually, the assured sum is equivalent to 50% of the final salary received.
  • The government bears the cost of the pension. This scheme was discontinued in 2004.

The New Pension Scheme:

  • The government introduced NPS for its employees after it was initially designed for workers in the unorganized sector.
  • NPS for Central Government employees was announced on December 22, 2003, and became mandatory for all new government hires from January 1, 2004.
  • The defined contribution consisted of a matching contribution from the government and 10% of the employee’s base salary and dearness allowance. The government’s share of the basic pay and dearness allowance increased to 14% in January 2019.

Comparison: Guaranteed Pension Scheme Vs Old Pension Scheme Vs New Pension Scheme

Guaranteed Pension Scheme: Old Pension Scheme: New Pension Scheme:
  • This is a Defined Benefit Plan where the employer guarantees a specific retirement benefit to an employee based on a formula considering the employee’s salary and tenure of service.
  • The employer takes on the investment risk and is responsible for ensuring that there are adequate funds to provide the pension benefit.
  • This plan is typically offered to government employees and some private companies in India.
  • This is a Defined Benefit Plan offered to government employees who joined service before January 1, 2004.
  • Under this scheme, the employee is entitled to a fixed pension, which is calculated based on their length of service and the average of their last 10 months’ salary before retirement.
  • The government is responsible for funding the pension and is required to contribute a certain percentage of the employee’s salary towards the pension fund.
  • This is a Defined Contribution Plan offered to government and private sector employees.
  • Under this scheme, the employee contributes a certain percentage of their salary towards the pension fund, and the employer also makes a matching contribution.
  • The funds are then invested in various asset classes, such as equities, bonds, and government securities, based on the employee’s risk appetite.
  • At retirement, the employee can withdraw a portion of the corpus as a lump sum, and the remaining amount is used to purchase an annuity that provides a regular income stream.

Conclusion :

  • The main distinctions between these schemes lie in their structure and management. The Guaranteed Pension Scheme and the Old Pension Scheme are Defined Benefit Plans, where the benefit is fixed and guaranteed, and the employer is responsible for funding it.
  • The New Pension Scheme is a Defined Contribution Plan, where the benefit depends on the contributions made by the employee and the investment returns earned on these contributions. Here, the employee bears the investment risk.
  • Furthermore, the Guaranteed Pension Scheme and Old Pension Scheme are typically offered to government employees, while the New Pension Scheme is offered to both government and private sector employees.
Related Links
World Sickle Cell Day Himalayan Griffon Vulture
List of Joint Military Exercises of the Indian Army Provincial Kingdoms of Medieval India
The Deccan Kingdoms Pahari Paintings
Frequently Asked Questions

Promo Banner

UPSC Beginners Program

Get UPSC Beginners Program - 60 Days Foundation Course SuperCoaching @ just

500000
🪙 Your Total Savings ₹50000

Want to know more about this Super Coaching ?

People also like

Public Administration optional by Rahul Sharma Sir

Public Administration optional by Rahul Sharma Sir

30000(59% OFF)

12500 (Valid for 15 Months)

Hindi Literature Optional (UPSC Mains) by Prachi Choudhary Ma'am

Hindi Literature Optional (UPSC Mains) by Prachi Choudhary Ma'am

33000(73% OFF)

9000 (Valid for 15 Months)

PSIR Optional (UPSC Mains) by Kiran Anishetty Sir

PSIR Optional (UPSC Mains) by Kiran Anishetty Sir

30000(40% OFF)

18000 (Valid for 15 Months)

Report An Error

Open this in:

Testbook LogoTestbook App
ChromeChrome